BY ALAN STEIN
Published in the Waterbury Sunday Republican on October 27, 2024.
The war Yahya Sinwar started has been devastating for the Gazans in what de facto has been an independent state since Israel completely left in 2005. Sinwar embedded Hamas' infrastructure throughout the world's most massive underground complex, locating terror tunnels under almost every school, mosque and hospital along with countless homes. This makes him responsible for the massive destruction throughout Gaza.
The tens of thousands of rockets Hamas accumulated were stored and launched from the same places, which also contained Hamas bases and command centers.
With Sinwar and virtually every other Hamas leader eliminated, we're hearing voices, including from our American government, asserting it's time to end the war, with many repeating Hamas' false allegations of massive civilian deaths.
In modern urban warfare, the United Nations expects almost 9 civilian casualties for every combatant death; in Gaza the ratio has been in the neighborhood of 1 to 1, with Hamas privately admitting that 80% of the casualties were Hamas or members of their family.
Perhaps the most astounding aspect of Sinwar's war is how historically low Israel has kept the proportion of civilian casualties.
After Sinwar was taken out, President Biden issued a written statement praising his elimination but including the words "There is now the opportunity for a 'day after' in Gaza without Hamas in power, and for a political settlement that provides a better future for Israelis and Palestinians alike."
Similarly, Vice President Harris said "It is time for the day after to begin."
Their words are premature. The way this war ends is more important than when it ends. We should have learned that lesson. Each of the Gaza wars since the first one Hamas started in 2008, including those in 2014, 2021 and the current one, were made inevitable because the previous one was ended prematurely.
Hamas must be vanquished the way the Germans and Japanese were in World War II and Hamas' entire terror infrastructure must be destroyed. This includes its tunnels, its rockets, its weapons and its ammunition. The Philadelphi Corridor, the border between Gaza and Egypt, must be secured so that rockets and other weapons cannot again be smuggled across, over or under it.
Otherwise the end of this war will be a prelude to the next war, with all the funds invested in rebuilding Gaza once again being wasted.
There is the question of who can be trusted to take those steps necessary to prevent Hamas from resurrecting itself and starting yet another war.
It can't be the Palestinian Authority, which is dominated by Fatah and rewards terrorists with its infamous pay-to-slay program. The PA's leader, Mahmoud Abbas, is also the leader of both the PLO and Fatah. Fatah used its Facebook page to proudly boast of its participation in Oct. 7 and officially mourned the elimination of Sinwar. The PLO issued a statement including "The Executive Committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization expresses its condolences to the Palestinian people and all national factions on the martyrdom of the great national leader Yahya Sinwar."
It can't be the United Nations, which is institutionally hostile to Israel and whose agencies have been complicit with both Hamas and Hezbollah.
UNRWA allowed its facilities, including schools and hospitals, to be used to shield Hamas rockets, bases and control centers. Hamas' main data center was located directly beneath UNRWA's Gaza headquarters, which also supplied the data center with power. Thousands of its employees are Hamas terrorists, including an UNRWA teacher who served as one of Sinwar's bodyguards and was killed along with Sinwar.
The Europeans can't be trusted.
After the 2014 war, because of the way Hamas was known to steal so much of the aid sent to Gaza, they assured Israel they would put procedures in place guaranteeing Hamas couldn't steal any of the aid they sent. Those assurances proved worthless, as Hamas succeeded in stealing an estimated 90% of the cement sent to Gaza for reconstruction and used it to construct its enormous complex of terror tunnels.
Even the United States can't be trusted. Eleven days after Hamas' Oct. 7 attack, President Biden said "Let me be clear: If Hamas diverts or steals the assistance [he pledged to send to Gaza], they will have demonstrated once again that they have no concern for the welfare of the Palestinian people and it will end." It quickly became clear Hamas was stealing most of the aid, yet Biden not only didn't stop sending aid, but kept increasing it and pressuring Israel to allow even more, supplying and providing a lifeline to Hamas.
This leaves Israel as the only party with both the ability and willingness to do what's needed to prevent the end of this war from setting the stage for yet another war.
Israel has provided an opportunity to end this war in a way that will end the role of Gaza as a mini-terror state bringing misery, death and destruction to the people in Gaza while constantly attacking Israel.
A year ago, President Biden said Hamas had to be eliminated. America needs to stand firmly with Israel and let it complete that task.
Alan Stein, Ph.D., is a former longtime resident of Waterbury. He and his wife Marsha currently split their time between Netanya in Israel and Natick, Mass. He is president emeritus of PRIMER-Connecticut (Promoting Responsibility in Middle East Reporting) and the founder of PRIMER-Massachusetts and PRIMER-Israel.